Review: The Dead Hour by Denise Mina


The Dead HourPaddy Meehan is the kind of character who stays in your brain and has you wanting more. Like Maureen O’Donnell in Denise Mina’s earlier Garnethill trilogy, Paddy is a plucky battler in a grim Glasgow. The Dead Hour is set in Thatcher’s Britain against the backdrop of epoch-ending changes to the newspaper world.

This is the second of Denise Mina’s books about Paddy Meehan, who has moved from a copy boy at a traditional daily newspaper to being the night shift crime reporter. Although it’s recognised that the night shift is there only as insurance against the death of the Queen Mother or similarly major event, Paddy does take it seriously as a stepping stone to something better.

While attending a police call-out to a noise complaint, Paddy sees an injured woman, but does nothing, nor do the police. The rest of the book is a tense and thrilling unravelling of events at the house and subsequently. Thanks to the author, we get to see the action from the vantage points of different characters directly involved in the story and the chain of tragic actions that underpin it. This means that we get to see and appreciate the dogged and clever way that Paddy works through what she knows and sees in order to resolve the story, at some risk to herself.

T he brilliance of the writing is in the way that Paddy’s character and spirit are conveyed by her interactions with the journalists and police, family and friends that make up her Glasgow. The lives of poor, unemployed, Irish Catholics, the corruption of some policemen but the dedication of others, the unthinking chauvinism of the men she works with, not to mention her own battles with food and figure, and her engagement with them, all make Paddy Meehan a memorable character.

But its not just Paddy. All of the characters are carefully drawn – the cocaine queen Kate, who brings it all about, Paddy’s ex-boyfriend Sean, her mother Tricia, the policeman George Burns, who is also a comedian and more, and Farquarson, the editor – and the plot rattles along to a conclusion. There are a couple of stings to the tail to ponder about for the next book in the series, The Last Breath. I can’t wait.

Details: Publisher: Bantam Books; ISBN-10: 0553818937; ISBN-13: 978-0553818932

Other novels by Denise Mina:

Garnethill, Exile, Resolution – Garnethill trilogy; Sanctum; The Field of Blood – Paddy Meehan


3 Responses to Review: The Dead Hour by Denise Mina

  1. qugrainne says:

    Thanks for the delightful words:Mina is one of my new, favorites. I was pleased, but not surprised to see your enthusiastic review. Have you read her Maureen O’Donnell trio? I think you would find them equally satisfying. I enjoy going to author websites and checking out whether or not they are human. Mina most definitely is!

  2. Hugh McPhail says:

    Yes, the first Denise Mina books I read were the Maureen O’Donnell trio. There she created another compelling character – very edgy but with such a sense of being firmly based in real life. I do think that of the authors I have read over the last few years she is the best.

  3. I noticed that this is not the first time at all that you write about this topic. Why have you chosen it again?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: